Dutch Elm Disease Struck in the Mid-1950s
by Dave Vogel
Historic Wauwatosa, Issue 226, May 2015

Twenty years after Mayor William B. Knuese declared war on Dutch elm disease in 1956, the battles raged on, and a helicopter hovered low over streets of Wauwatosa.

“The disease usually starts at the top,” Prill said. “I’d record which trees needed to be checked and we’d use a boom truck and a pruning pole to see if it had the disease. If we caught it soon enough, we could remove branches before it got to the larger section of the tree.”
From the vantage of a chopper, arborist Allen Prill could survey the city’s thousands of elms.
Sometimes, the trees could be saved. But the helicopter noise resulted in so many complaints to City Hall that aerial surveying soon was abandoned.
The only weapon in the arborist’s arsenal then was DDT, at least until 1973, when it was effectively banned after President Richard Nixon signed the Endangered Species Act.
With an estimated 7,000 elm trees, more than neighboring cities, Wauwatosa had a lot at stake. The city responded quickly and aggressively.
The disease had been spreading across the country since the 1930s, so its arrival was more heartbreaking than surprising. The first case in Milwaukee County was discovered in Wauwatosa in July 1956 at 6607 W. Lloyd St. A few weeks later, a second diseased tree was found at 608 N. 116th St.

That August, Mayor Knuese met with about 150 of the city’s 800 civil defense block wardens and declared war. The wardens were drafted to serve as foot soldiers and inspect trees in their neighborhoods each week.

The city bought a second and then a third blower that month to mist the trees with DDT. For a time, the three sprayers were in use 16 hours a day, seven days a week. The first crews worked from 4 a.m. to noon and then handed over the misting machines to a fresh crew that worked until 8 p.m.
Kits to detect the disease were distributed to all the public schools for use even by elementary students. It was a hands-on science lesson.
“If we lose our elm trees,” city forester Howard Muellner told the Kiwanis Club, “this will be a sickly looking city.”
Even aerial spraying of the trees was considered, but ruled out as ineffective.
Crews sometimes overlapped and some trees were sprayed more than once. “But we’d rather spray one street twice than miss a street,” Muellner said.
Most of the elms lined city streets, but city crews also sprayed elms on private property, if they could get their equipment near.
Spraying continued until cold weather arrived that December. By the end of 1956, samples from 52 trees had been sent to a state lab and five were diseased. Effects of the disease were gradual, but the devastation was total along some streets.
Sunlight filtered through elms and created an otherworldly experience on many streets. There was a serenity, almost a sacredness, when walking under leafy high-arching cathedrals of elms.
“Warren Avenue and 89th Street, between North Avenue and Meinecke, had some of the original elms,” Prill said. “The canopy was so thick, the streets were almost dark.”
Prill fought throughout the Dutch elm war. He was hired as a city arborist in 1952 at age 19. He retired in 1991. Diseased trees were cut down and the wood burned to prevent elm bark beetles from infecting other trees. When the trees were gone, unsightly utility poles and wires that previously lurked in the shadow of the elms became visible.
Prill remembers spraying when the wind would change direction, dousing himself in a mist of DDT. “I could taste it,” he said. “It was bitter. Birds drinking from puddles would begin to tremble. I’m surprised it hasn’t killed me.”
Wauwatosa’s biggest loss in the war came in 1968 when the state’s oldest and largest elm, near the Menomonee River and Center Street, had to be cut down. Its age was estimated to be 296 years. At a point four feet from the ground, the 145-foot-tall tree was 21 feet, 2 inches around.
Disease-resistant varieties of the American elm have developed in recent years and some have been planted in Wauwatosa. So far, all remain healthy, a forestry official said.
Losing concentrations of the trees convinced city officials that elms should be replaced with a greater variety of tree species. For example, long columns of flowering crabs shout out for attention for a couple of weeks each May on Jackson Park Blvd. But the uniformity of those columns is interrupted by towering old trees that predate the crabs.
The war continues. The city has cut down more than 600 old-growth elms during the past 15 years. Only 361 survive.
Residents with city elm trees in front of their homes are contacted by the city early each spring and asked if they want the trees treated. The city uses a fungicide, Arbortect 20-S. The residents are asked to pay for the chemicals, usually about $30 to $55 per tree. There are no guarantees, but the fungicide is one of the few options available to hold off the disease.
It will take years for the city to fully recover from the Dutch elm war.
Wauwatosa also appears to be recovering from its DDT overdose. Thanks to the Endangered Species Act and the ban on DDT, the bald eagle, national bird of the United States, is making a comeback. So is the peregrine falcon.
And in Wauwatosa, fireflies are back. After a long stretch of years when the lightning bugs were absent from early summer evenings, the enchanting fireflies have returned in recent years.
It makes one wonder whether the DDT ban played a part in the firefly’s resurgence, too.
Their return is especially good news for Wauwatosa. By legend, the name Wauwatosa is said to be a Potawatomi word for firefly. Well, maybe.

You must be logged in to post a comment.